Home
reviews
album list
Melanie C
CMU
C.O.M.A.
Cadillac Sky
Caedmon's Call
Caesars (Palace)
Robyn Cage
Andrés Calamaro
Calexico
Calhoun
Cali
Eddie Callahan
Calliope
Hilario Camacho
Camel


Melanie C  (UK)

Melanie C, 'Reason'

Reason  (2003,  43.32)  **/0

Here it Comes Again
Reason
Lose Myself in You
On the Horizon
Positively Somewhere
Melt
Do I
Soul Boy
Water
Home
Let's Love
Yeh, Yeh, Yeh
Melanie C, 'This Time'

This Time  (2007,  48.48)  *½/0

Understand
What if I Stay
Protected
This Time
Carolyna
Forever Again
Your Mistake
The Moment You Believe
Don't Let Me Go
Immune
May Your Heart
Out of Time
I Want Candy

Current availability:

Mellotrons used:

So what does an ex-Spice Girl do with herself when her route to fame and fortune splits asunder? Crapola solo career, of course. Melanie "C" Chisholm, a.k.a. Sporty Spice, is one of the two Spice Girls who could actually sing; I can attest to this, as I worked as an extra on their dreadful film, and was (un)fortunate enough to witness their between-takes attempts at five-part harmony onstage at the Albert Hall, and it was only the two Mels would could hold a tune at all. A cat's chorus had nothing on them, believe me... Anyway, Ms. Chisholm has been mooted as the ex-Spice most likely to make it, which is pretty scary (ho ho).

Her first solo album, the indie-friendly Northern Star (she's a Liverpudlian) did fairly well, but the anodyne Reason has apparently blown any credibility its predecessor may've engendered. What's so bad about it? It's bland, her vocals are terrible (did I say she could sing?), the material's rubbish... Need I say more? Mellotron credited on track four, On The Horizon, played by Rick Nowells, who added Chamberlin to a couple of tracks on Dido's horrible No Angel, but I'll be fucked if I can hear it. Yeah, there's a string part, but it sounds far more like real ones than any form of tape-replay, and certainly does nothing to enhance the already gruesome song to which it's attached.

Has anything improved in Mel C-land by 2007? Going by that year's This Time, containing the blandest, least interesting mainstream pop you can imagine, the answer has to be 'no'. Saying that, so-called 'R&B' is worse; Mel's faintly rootsy, quite 'trad' pop sounding almost good in comparison, but only in comparison. Is there a best track? Maybe Out Of Time, with some raucous guitar work, while her cover of The Strangeloves' I Want Candy is at least recognisable. Out Of Time also has credited Mellotron from Phil Thornalley, but I have to say, once again, whatever it's supposed to be doing is entirely inaudible.

Anyway; don't, under any circumstances, buy these album (like, you were going to), just on the remote offchance you were thinking about it. They're crap and there's no audible Mellotron.

Official site

CMU  (UK)

CMU, 'Space Cabaret'

Space Cabaret  (1972,  42.28)  ***½/T

Space Cabaret
Archway 272
Song From the 4th Era
A Distant Thought, a Point of Light
Doctor, am I Normal?
Dream
Lightshine

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Cambridge-based CMU (Contemporary Music Unit, apparently) were a sort of folky/bluesy/proggish outfit, like so many at the turn of the '70s, and they managed a couple of albums that are probably as much sought after now for their rarity value as their musical worth. Their debut, Open Spaces (***½) isn't actually bad; in fact, its psych-ish title track is well worth hearing, but overall it really isn't that exciting.

By their 2nd album, Space Cabaret, CMU had moved away from their bluesy roots into a more folk/psych direction, although they could also rock out when the mood took them. There's some really nice moments on the album, but it's no classic, to be honest, and a bit dated for '72. There's a fair bit of Mellotron strings on Archway 272 (presumably referring to the area of North London), but I wouldn't buy it for that alone.

So; not a bad album, a bit of 'Tron, that's about it, really.

C.O.M.A.  (France)

C.O.M.A., 'Clinik Organik Muzak Anatomik'

Clinik Organik Muzak Anatomik  (1979,  35.50)  ***½/½

Introx
Parking Nord
Le Roi des Voleurs
Tête de Gomme
Femme-Robot
Coma
Assaut
Verre
Hypnose
La Valse a Mutant
Conséquences
Demain

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

C.O.M.A., or Clinik Organik Muzak Anatomik, were a French new wave/synth outfit, not dissimilar to the better-known Metal Urbain, much championed by John Peel at the time, I seem to recall. So why haven't we heard of this lot? It's pretty random what music travels and what doesn't, I've found and for some reason, it seems copies of Clinik Organik Muzak Anatomik (or whatever it's actually called) rarely found their way out of the country, although I wouldn't be entirely surprised if a certain Dave Ball heard it; closer Demain reminds me slightly of Soft Cell's Bedsitter, two years early. Stylistically, it mixes spiky new wave guitars with dissonant synths and mostly electronic drums, topped off with Philippe "P.R." Ross' vocal monotone, sounding every bit as alienated and other-wordly as any post-punk outfit you'd care to name.

Two Mellotron tracks, with the quietest of quiet choirs on Coma itself from Philippe Huart and a brief burst of very recognisable church organ, complete with superbly inauthentic pitchbend, on closer Demain from Marc Desmullier. Long out of print (of course), this has been made available on various blogs, which (you never know) might even precipitate an official reissue. An almost unknown minor classic of the era, this is well worth hearing, though not, sadly, for its Mellotron use.

CRX  (US)  see: Samples

Cadillac Sky  (US)

Cadillac Sky, 'Letters in the Deep'

Letters in the Deep  (2010,  48.39)  ***½/½

Trapped Under the Ice
3rd Degree
Human Cannonball
Trash Bag
Lee of the Stone: East
Ballad of Restored Confidence
Hangman
Break My Heart Again
Lee of the Stone: West
Hypocrite
Kiddie Pool Rag
Bathsheeba
Pitiful Waltz
Part of My Heart
Lee of the Stone: North
Tired Old Phrases
The Long Sigh

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Cadillac Sky, unsurprisingly, peddle a variety of Americana than leans heavily towards the bluegrass end of things, rich with fiddles, banjos and mandolins. 2010's Letters in the Deep is their third album, recorded live in the studio, veering between the bluegrass/rock of opener Trapped Under The Ice through the punk bluegrass of Bathsheeba and the more straightforward bulk of the record, highlights including Trash Bag and Lee Of The Stone: West.

David Mayfield, Matthew Menefee and Ross Holmes are all credited with Mellotron, which is rather surprising given that the only things I can hear are a pitchbent something opening 3rd Degree and more obvious distant choirs on Trash Bag. You're not going to buy this record for its minimal Mellotron use, though, but for its trick of combining tradition with innovation so seamlessly that you can't see the join. Well worth hearing.

Official site

Caedmon's Call  (US)

Caedmon's Call, '40 Acres'

40 Acres  (1999,  44.42)  **/T

There You Go
Thankful
Shifting Sand
Faith My Eyes
Where I Began
Table for Two
Climb on (a Back That's Strong)
Petrified Heart
Somewhere North
Daring Daylight Escape
40 Acres
'City on a Hill: It's Christmas Time'

City on a Hill: It's Christmas Time  (2002,  4.56)  **/½

[Caedmon's Call contribute]
Babe in the Straw

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Caedmon's Call are at the folkier end of the CCM spectrum, although Cliff Young's vocals come straight from the 'indie/alternative' school, particularly the irritating near-hiccup with which he ends many lines. They're notable in Christian circles for Derek Webb's on/off membership, although he has a successful solo career of his own. 1999's 40 Acres was their third album and I'd imagine it's pretty typical of their sound; a rather lifeless male and/or female-fronted Christian thing, with those horrible vocals that so many modern practitioners (and not just Christian ones) insist on using; you know, the 'fake-emotive' type than can turn a reasonable man homicidal.

Keys man Randy Holsapple plays Mellotron on Petrified Heart, with a nice flute part on one of the album's better songs, if you ignore the vocals and lyrics (not easy, I'll admit). So; not as offensive as a lot of CCM, but ruined by awful vocals. Shame. Anyway, one passable 'Tron track, that's it. Caedmon's also contribute to the horrible City on a Hill series, adding Babe In The Straw to the third volume, It's Christmas Time, with a Chamberlin string part from Phil Madeira that doesn't especially add anything to anything.

Official site

See: Derek Webb | Bebo Norman | City on a Hill

Caesars (Palace)  (Sweden)

Caesars Palace, 'Cherry Kicks'

Cherry Kicks  [as Caesars Palace]  (2000,  39.58)  ***½/T

Right About Time
Subhuman Girl
Crackin' Up
One Good Night
Spill Your Guts
Since You've Been Gone
Oh Yeah?
Punkrocker
Fun & Games
From the Bughouse
Only You
Cherry Kicks
Caesars, 'Paper Tigers'

Paper Tigers  [as Caesars]  (2005,  47.42)  ***½/T

Spirit
Not That Fall That Hurts
Out There
Jerk it Out
May the Rain
My Heart is Breaking Down
Paper Tigers
Your Time Is Near
Throwaway
Winter Song
We Got to Leave
Soul Chaser
Good and Gone
(Iím Gonna) Kick You Out

Current availability:

Mellotrons used:

From a country excelling in all things garage (rock), Sweden's Caesars Palace (later Caesars, or Twelve Caesars in the rest of Scandinavia), named for vocalist/guitarist César Vidal, have raised the bar a notch or three, matching The Hives for sheer '60s-influenced excellence. Saying that, the band have developed their own take on it, ending up sounding like nobody but themselves, which has to be applauded. I believe Cherry Kicks is their second album, although the first as Caesars Palace, full of energetic, tuneful garage rock (Spill Your Guts is typical), with the odd sideways step like the rather odd slowie Since You've Been Gone. One Good Night opens with a beautiful solo Mellotron flute part from David Nyström, sounding nicely authentic, although as so often, it might have been nice to hear it a little more.

Five years on, Paper Tigers is their fourth album proper, ignoring a 2003 compilation and once again, it's stuffed full of great hooks and a vibrant, upbeat distorted Farfisa-driven sound. My only real criticism is that it's too long; any more than, say, 35 minutes of this stuff is a bit much, to be honest, but that's just being picky. There's an interview snippet on their website where Joakim Åhlund, talking about their studio, says, "We have a Mellotron and all our old mics and amps and things", although it isn't credited in the CD booklet, and there aren't any pictures, so I don't even know who plays it. Sadly, it's only obvious on one song, with a full-on string part on Winter Song, with the Farfisa and Philips Philicorda organs sharing the bulk of the keyboard work between them.

So; two damn' good albums, although hardcore progheads are unlikely to be too amused. Like the band give a shit, I'd imagine... Good, though thin on the 'Tron.

Official site

Robyn Cage  (US)

Robyn Cage, 'Tales of a Thief'

Tales of a Thief  (2014,  22.21)  **½/½

Burning Now
The Arsonist & the Thief
If You Don't Try
The Cave
Cinderella Story
Theatre Noir

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Robyn "Cage" Kemp is a new American singer-songwriter, her 2014 EP Tales of a Thief, being her first release under her nom de plume. And it's... twee, mainstream pop of the 'music for sensitive people' variety; harmless, but somewhat on the unexciting side, to say the least. Is there a 'best track'? Closer Theatre Noir, complete with Cage's 'silent movie'-style upright piano taps into her country's carney tradition in reasonably pleasing fashion, although it's not enough to rescue the EP from overall mediocrity.

Zac Rae (Fiona Apple, Macy Gray), plays Mellotron, with a chordal string part towards the end of Theatre Noir; hardly the most overt use ever, but at least it's there. Saying that, Sara Lov has posted a picture on Facebook of Mr. Rae cheerfully holding an M4000D Mini sample player, labelled 'Zac Rae on mellotron', so I'm not at all sure we can trust his recent 'Mellotron' credits.

Official site

Cage the Elephant  (US)  see: Samples

Calabrese  (US)  see: Samples

Andrés Calamaro  (Argentina)

Andrés Calamaro, 'Alta Suciedad'

Alta Suciedad  (1997,  55.13)  **½/½

Alta Suciedad
Todo Lo Demás También
Donde Manda Marinero
Loco
Flaca
Quién Asó la Manteca?
Media Verónica
El Tercio de los Sueños
Comida China
Elvis está Vivo
Me Arde
Crimenes Perfectos
Nunca es Igual
El Novio del Olvido

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Andrés Calamaro is apparently one of Argentina's top entertainers, his career path arcing through Los Abuelos de la Nada, Los Rodríguez and concurrent solo albums. 1997's Alta Suciedad (translates as 'high dirt', which highlights the inadequacies of online translation software) largely consists of Latin pop/rock and ballads, although the opening title track is a dirty, brass-driven rock number. Despite my effectively nonexistent Spanish, even I can translate Elvis Está Vivo... No he ain't, Andrés, and the song's really dull to boot.

Calamaro plays Mellotron on Comida China himself, with an obviously Mellotronic string part running through the song. Now, given that I don't believe there was a single Mellotron in South America until a few years ago (I now know of two), I can only assume the album, or at least part of it, was recorded in an American or European studio. Either that, or it's samples, but it doesn't actually sound like it. Anyway, you're not going to buy this for one so-so 'Tron track, so it's all a bit academic, really.

Official site

Kathryn Calder  (Canada)  see: Samples

Calexico  (US)

Calexico, 'Edge of the Sun'

Edge of the Sun  (2015,  58.06)  ***/T

Falling From the Sky
Bullets & Rocks
When the Angels Played
Tapping on the Line
Cumbia de Donde
Miles From the Sea
Coyoacán
Beneath the City of Dreams
Woodshed Waltz
Moon Never Rises
World Undone
Follow the River

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

As I said in my Calexico samples review, they were formed by two ex-Giant Sand members and play a unique variety of Tex-Mex Americana, for want of a better term. 2015's Edge of the Sun is their ninth album, not that dissimilar to 2012's Algiers, featuring a good bit of stylistic diversity, from country-rock opener Falling From The Sky through the vaguely ZZ Top-esque Bullets & Rocks, the very country When The Angels Played, the mariachi electronica (!) of Cumbia De Donde to the slow burn of World Undone, seeming longer than it is in a good way.

Sergio Mendoza's credited Mellotron actually sounds quite real on opener Falling From The Sky, the string line running through the song sounding authentically wobbly, which makes a nice change. So; a decent enough album, good at what it does, one seemingly real Mellotron track. What a breath of fresh air after the swampfuls of crud I've listened to recently.

Official site

See: Samples | Giant Sand | Sweetheart 2005: Love Songs

Calhoun  (US)

Calhoun, 'Heavy Sugar'

Heavy Sugar  (2011,  42.45)  **/½

Knife Fight
Thrown in the Universe
Lioness
Horsefeathers
Heart of Junk
Don't Let Go
The Engineer
Indian Melody
Ryders
Snow Day
Hey! Mystery
Black Coffee & Cigarettes

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Calhoun are an indie/Americana quintet from Fort Worth, Texas, whose fourth album, 2011's Heavy Sugar (the title coming from the lyric to Horsefeathers), might be more listenable had the band listened to and learned from artists further away from the indie mainstream. Rhythmically, this is a disaster, at its least bad on its quieter tracks, notably Lioness and Snow Day, although Tim Locke's vocals irritate throughout, just to help matters along.

Nolan Thies plays (real?) Mellotron, with strings on Heart Of Junk, although all other string sounds seem to be generic samples. No, I did not like this. No, I do not recommend it. If you want Americana, there are hundreds of better artists out there.

Official site

Cali  (France)

Cali, 'Menteur'

Menteur  (2005,  52.53)  ***/T

Qui se Soucie de Moi
Je M'en Vais (Après Miossec)
Pauvre Garçon
Pour Jane
Je Sais
Je Ne Vivrai Pas Sans Toi
Roberta
Menteur
Tes Yeux
La Fin du Monde Pour dans 10 Minutes
Je Te Souhaite à Mon Pire Ennemi
Le Vrai Père
Cali, 'L'Espoir'

L'Espoir  (2008,  50.51/55.58)  ***/T

L'Espoir
Je Ne Te Reconnais Plus
1000 Cœurs Debout
Comme J'Étais en Vie
Je Suis Laid
Sophie Calle N°108
Résistance
Amoureuse
Pas la Guerre
Giuseppe et Maria
Les Beaux Jours Approchent
Je Me Sens Belle
Paola
Le Droit des Pères
[Bonus track:
List of Lies]

Current availability:

Mellotrons used:

Bruno "Cali" Caliciuri's second release was a live DVD, which seems to indicate towering ambition and self-confidence, although given that he's already racking up French music awards, perhaps he has a point. 2005's Menteur is only his second album, a confident, fairly mainstream folk and jazz-influenced effort, shifting between French-language pop/rock (opener Qui Se Soucie De Moi, Je Ne Vivrai Pas Sans Toi), the aforementioned folk/jazz influences (Je M'En Vais (Après Miossec), Pour Jane), fairly typical chanson (Je Sais) and bordering-avant orchestral closer Le Vrai Père. Daniel Presley plays Mellotron flutes on Je Sais, wobbly enough to be real, although all string parts sound genuine.

Two albums down the line, 2008's L'Espoir isn't wildly different to Menteur, Cali tackling a similar combination of styles, even adding kind-of Celtic hard rock to the mix on Résistance. One notable feature of the album is the involvement of The Waterboys' Mike Scott, who adds his suitably Mike Scott-esque tones to Pas La Guerre and the bonus track on some editions, List Of Lies, both adorned with Waterboys-esque brass. Julien Lebart plays Mellotron flutes on Giuseppe Et Maria and Je Me Sens Belle, but again, the strings are real.

Non-French-speakers probably aren't going to get too much from Cali's work, although he's no slouch on the musical front and a million miles from the kind of insipid modern singer-songwriter guff that clogs up the world's airwaves. Two decent albums within their own milieu, then, with a little Mellotron on each.

Official site

Eddie Callahan  (US)

Eddie Callahan, 'False Ego'

False Ego  (1976,  38.38)  ***½/TT

Where Will We Be Tomorrow
Just Across the Line
Shake Your Woogie
Santa Cruz Mountains
Don't You Know
Dying to Sing
Paper Rain
Lonely Feelings
Judge Me
Flying

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Eddie Callahan's Hare Krishna beliefs almost certainly influenced the 'questing' lyrics on what may well be his sole album, 1976's damn' near private-pressing False Ego. This highly collectible album sits somewhere in between folk, psych and mid-'70s mainstream rock, soundly oddly like a powerpop/proto-new wave cross at points, notably on Dying To Sing, while Just Across The Line reminds me, obscurely, of Syd Barrett. Despite what must've been a rock-bottom budget, the album's full of neat little production tricks, not least the way Dying To Sing's electric backing fades under the vocals, to be replaced by acoustic guitar for the last few lines, the mental synth effects on Paper Rain or the arranged harmony synth parts on several tracks.

Bob (now better known as Robert) Berry plays Mellotron, presumably his own M400, apparently also heard on his band Hush's contemporaneous debut, as yet unheard 'round these parts. Anyway, we get a lovely string part on Santa Cruz Mountains, subtle at first, but building in intensity through the song, a similar part on Paper Rain (alongside real strings) and a distinctly 'orchestral substitute' part on closer Flying, interspersed with choirs. Are you a fan of oddball folk/psych rarities, or borderline Krishna rock? Then you need to hear this, which, given that it's been reissued on CD, is far easier (and cheaper) than you might expect. Decent Mellotron work, too, used enough to be worthwhile, yet not so much that it becomes cheapened.

Calliope  (Italy)

Calliope, 'La Terra Dei Grandi Occhi'

La Terra Dei Grandi Occhi  (1992,  46.25)  ***½/TTT

La Terra Dei Grandi Occhi
Non ci Credo Più
Lunario
Pensieri Affascinanti
Passi Dentro il Tempo
Avalon
L'Anima del Cielo
Mellotronmania
Calliope, 'Citta di Frontiera'

Città di Frontiera  (1994,  49.59)  ****/TTT½

La Prova
Sarajevo
Margherita a Rodi
Terra di Nessuno

Senza Pretese
Windsor
L'Attesa
Il Ritorno
Calliope, 'Il Madrigale del Vento'

Il Madrigale del Vento  (1995,  52.53)  ***/TT

Terra di Maggio
La Nascita della Luna
En Haute de Crete

La Bionda Treccia
Il Tempo Sei Tu
La Visione della Dolce Pioggia

Current availability:

Mellotrons used:

Calliope are one of those bands who, for me, were initially very impressive, but whose appeal palled as time went by. After hearing a friend's copy of Città di Frontiera, I was completely blown away, bought it immediately and played it to death, although after picking up their debut, La Terra Dei Grandi Occhi, I was rather less impressed. Playing these back-to-back, I was very aware of their shortcomings; for an Italian progressive outfit, they lack subtlety, and their retro leanings are heavily tempered with a '90s guitar sound and style, despite the (authentic) '70s keys.

La Terra Dei Grandi Occhi tries hard, and given the prevalence of terrible neo- outfits doing the rounds in Italy at the time (have you ever HEARD Tale Cue?), Calliope's '70s influences came as a breath of fresh air. The song construction is rather straightforward compared to their forebears, however, with an obviousness to their compositions that would never have been tolerated by, for example, Le Orme, although some of the material actually dated back to that decade. The guitar parts are far too powerchord-based for comfort, too; they could never be mistaken for a long-lost '70s band, assuming that was actually the band's intention. As you can see, though, Rinaldo Doro used their beaten-up M400 on every single track, though to their credit, it's rarely overused, with little bursts of choir and flute among the more prevalent strings. The one outstanding piece of Mellotron work on the album, unsurprisingly, is the 90-second closing piece, Mellotronmania, consisting of a simple 'Tron flute theme, overdubbed with their other two sounds, building and repeating to fade.

Città di Frontiera opens with my favourite track on the album, La Prova, although it manages to be the only one sans Mellotron, apart from the beautiful 49-second acoustic guitar instrumental Senza Pretese. It's easier with hindsight to see the transition the band made from first album to second; the compositions are better, though still nowhere near those of their influences. Again, a certain obviousness pervades most of the material, with some irritating 'widdly' MiniMoog lines straight out of the Marillion songbook, and proto-progressive metal guitar lines doing their best to spoil otherwise quite nice songs. The Mellotron work is a bit more upfront, though, with the usual string washes on most tracks, and the occasional bit of choir. Not a classic, but an improvement on their debut.

Between Calliope's second and third albums, their line-up changed radically, with only two members (keyboards and drums) remaining. The difference is immediately apparent, as Il Madrigale del Vento removes the heavier end of the band's sound, adds female vocals and changes their approach to a more obviously neo-prog one, albeit with some unexpected folk touches, not least on the traditional En Haute De Crete. While not a bad album, it smacks a little too much of many contemporaneous Italian neo-prog acts like Theatre, though thankfully nowhere near as bad. The opening and closing tracks are both in the 16-17 minute range, rather stretching the composers' skills, to be honest, although the shorter material in between is more cohesive.

I'm assuming the Mellotron's real and is presumably still played by Doro, one of two keyboard players on the album, along with Enrico Perrucci. The album's choirs really don't sound Mellotronic at all, which is perturbing (in a rather unimportant, non life-changing kind of way), but the strings on the first three tracks sound real enough. Maybe they just didn't like the choir sound any more? Sampled strings crop up in places, too, not least throughout Il Tempo Sei Tu, overlaid with real violin. Whether we're actually hearing a real Mellotron here has to be a moot point; going by some of Calliope's contemporaries, poorly-maintained or just plain old 'Trons were breaking down right, left and centre by the mid-'90s, before Streetly Electronics' refurbishment service became more widely known.

So; while sounding pretty good at the time, Calliope have been rather overtaken by events, I fear. Ten years on, the prog audience has modern bands of far more sophistication to listen to, with the more retro outfits sounding far more 'authentic' than this, and frequently taking more care over their compositions, so I'm left giving only a cautious recommendation on both musical and Mellotronic fronts. 2002's Generazioni apparently consists of half-and-half new recordings and material taped in '93, but it all sounds like new recordings with 'Tron samples, so until/unless I find out otherwise, it shall reside in samples.

Official site

See: Samples

Calogero  (France)  see: Samples

Hilario Camacho  (Spain)

Hilario Camacho, 'La Estrella del Alba'

La Estrella del Alba  (1977,  36.36)  ***/T

La Estrella del Alba
Claros Sentimientos
Soledad y Silencio
La Casa del Pozo
Mis Oies Oisan la Roca, Mi
  Cabeza Sobre Nubes Va Flotando
Arquitecto de Sueños
Señora de Ojos Tristes
Guapachosa
Maria
El Paseo del Atardecer

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

As far as I can work out (English-language information is startlingly hard to find), Hilario Camacho was a mainstream Spanish pop/rock artist who released albums for over forty years, his swansong appearing posthumously in 2007. 1977's La Estrella del Alba was his fourth, to my knowledge, hitching a ride on Spain's late-flowering progressive scene in places, although the bulk of it's pretty ordinary stuff. My personal preference, unsurprisingly, is for the album's folkier offerings (La Casa Del Pozo), or the slightly proggier material (Arquitecto De Sueños, closing solo piano piece El Paseo Del Atardecer), although I have to say, nothing here made me jab at the 'next' button; even the mainstream stuff's inoffensive.

Jesús Pardo adds Mellotron to the album in true Spanish style, with flutes over string synth on the opening title track and Arquitecto De Sueños and as usual, no bloody strings. Why did they do this? Or not do it, as the case may be? Anyway, an acceptable enough effort, though somewhat lightweight on the prog front, with very little Mellotron.

Official site

Camel  (UK)

Camel, 'Camel'

Camel  (1973,  39.10/61.51)  ***½/T½

Slow Yourself Down
Mystic Queen
Six Ate
Separation
Never Let Go
Curiosity
Arubaluba
[remastered CD adds:
Never Let Go (single version)
Homage to the God of Light (live)]
Camel, 'Mirage'

Mirage  (1974,  38.02/68.10)  ****/TT (TT½)

Freefall
Supertwister
Nimrodel
  The Procession

  The White Rider

Earthrise
Lady Fantasy
  Encounter
  Smiles for You
  Lady Fantasy
[remastered CD adds:
Supertwister (live)
Mystic Queen (live)
Arubaluba (live)
Lady Fantasy (original mix)
  Encounter
  Smiles for You
  Lady Fantasy
]
Camel, 'Moonmadness'

Moonmadness  (1976,  39.15/71.27)  ****½/½

Aristillus
Song Within a Song
Chord Change
Spirit of the Water
Another Night
Air Born
Lunar Sea
[remastered CD adds:
Another Night (single version)
Spirit of the Water (demo)
Song Within a Song (live)
Lunar Sea (live)
Preparation/Dunkirk (live)]
Camel, 'The Single Factor'

The Single Factor  (1982,  38.52)  **/½

No Easy Answer
You Are the One
Heroes
Selva
Lullabye
Sasquatch
Manic
Camelogue
Today's Goodbye
A Heart's Desire
End Peace

Current availability:

Mellotrons used:

Camel were slightly late entrants to the progressive arena, not releasing their self-titled debut until 1973; Camel has a Canterbury-ish feel to it, but thankfully without the tedious whimsy and dull jazziness of many of the bands from the scene. Camel's strength was always their melodic invention, although they were still to refine it by this point in their career; their most noticeable weakness was in the vocal department, with various members singing on different tracks, all sounding a bit dodgy. Camel's a good album, without being at all outstanding, mostly organ- and guitar-driven, with highlights including Mystic Queen and Separation, with the punning Six Ate being a live favourite. Keyboard man Pete Bardens, with a string of solo albums already to his credit, only plays 'Mellatron' (aargh!) on one track, the excellent Never Let Go and while the string chords are nice, the standout part on the track is some rippling flute arpeggios, proving that you can play a well set-up Mellotron fast, if you know what you're doing. And no, that's not Andy Latimer on his second instrument.

The following year's Mirage was better, with more consistent songwriting, particularly the album's two 'epics', Nimrodel and Lady Fantasy. Mellotron on both, with the proverbial string washes (sorry), although Bardens' use never approaches that of many of his contemporaries' for sheer invention. Andy Latimer's guitar comes into its own on this album, with some beautiful soaring lead work on several tracks, notably Lady Fantasy, while he's no slouch on the flute, either. Definitely worth hearing.

Camel are best-known for their third album, '75's (Music Inspired By) The Snow Goose (****), an all-instrumental concept piece based on Paul Gallico's short story. Whimsical? Maybe, but the music is quite outstanding melodic prog, and the instrumental format suited the band well, making it strange that they never repeated the experiment. Sadly, there's no Mellotron to be heard on the album, presumably because of their use of an unnamed orchestra, arranged by Mike Oldfield collaborator David Bedford. They followed it up with another 'regular' release, '76's gorgeous Moonmadness, melody still to the fore, especially on the rather wonderful Song Within A Song. Mellotron on only one track this time (I've no idea whether Camel owned their own machine, or just hired them in for studio sessions; to my knowledge they never used one live), Air Born, yet another intensely melodic piece, with a few choir chords at the end, but that's it for the album's Mellotron use.

By 1982's The Single Factor, Camel were effectively a Latimer solo project, a status they've maintained to the present day; the album title alludes to this situation and although Bardens returns to guest on one track, this is most decidedly Latimer's show. There are guests a-plenty, including Anthony Phillips on guitar and keys, Duncan Mackay, David Paton (Alan Parsons etc.) and Francis Monkman (ex-Curved Air), although the album retains a stylistic homogeneity throughout. It has to be said that it isn't very good, although Sasquatch (Bardens' guest spot) and Manic on side two aren't so bad. Most of side one is horrible, pseudo-commercial dross, not even worthy of being released under the band's name, in my opinion; I can only assume the only reason it wasn't in actuality a Latimer solo record was the (admittedly declining) power of the Camel brand name. As far as the Mellotron's concerned, Latimer's credited with it on Manic, but alongside Ant Phillips' Polymoog and organ, it's as near to inaudible as you can get; I'm guessing that it's background strings you can (almost) hear, but it's rather hard to say. Avoid.

So, while never much of a 'Mellotron band', Camel's contribution to the progressive canon is noteworthy, without ever being likely to challenge the big boys. Their first four albums are all worth hearing, as is unsurprisingly Mellotron-free live archive release On the Road 1972 (****), although quality dips towards the end of the '70s and plummets soon after. Sadly, any vague hopes fans may have had for a reunion of the original lineup one day were dashed in early 2002 by news of Pete Bardens' death. Latimer's version of the band tour and record to this day, but keyboards these days are the usual digital dullness and despite some reasonably-acclaimed recent releases, Camel are most unlikely ever to produce anything even close to the quality of their early material again.

Official site

See: Harbour of Joy


previous pagenext page