album list
Ian McNabb
Shannon McNally
Machine & the Synergetic Nuts
Machines of Loving Grace
Mad Scene
The Mad Trist
Madden & Harris
Made in Sweden
Madison Dyke
Madrigal [UK]
Madrigal [France]
Lois Maffeo & Brendan Carty
Magic Numbers

Ian McNabb  (UK)

Ian McNabb, 'A Party Political Broadcast...'

A Party Political Broadcast on Behalf of the Emotional Party  (1998,  47.03)  ***½/T½

Sex With Someone You Love
A Guy Like Me (and a Girl Like You)
Loveless Age
You Only Get What You Deserve
The Man Who Can Make a Woman Laugh
Liverpool Girl
Absolutely Wrong
Little Princess
Girls Are Birds
Ian McNabb, 'Ian McNabb'

Ian McNabb  (2001,  59.42)  ****/TT

Livin' Proof (Miracles Can Happen)
Whatever it Takes
What You Wanted
Liverpool Girl
(If We Believe) What Love Can Do
Alright With Me
Hollywood Tears
Open Air
Nothin' Less Than the Very Best
Hotel Stationary
Rockin' for Jesus
Friend of My Enemy
Moment in the Sun
(I Wish I Was in) California
Ian McNabb, 'Waifs & Strays'

Waifs & Strays  (2001, recorded 1993-2000,  79.06)  ***½/TT

Loveless Age
Fire Inside My Soul
Gak Mummy No.1
I'm a Genius
Me and the Devil
Why Are the Beautiful So Sad?
Misty Meadows
Not Lost Enough to Be Rescued
Time of My Time
Great Dreams of Heaven
Nobody Say Nothin' to No One
You Stone My Soul
The New Golden Age
Ian McNabb, 'Before All of This'

Before All of This  (2005,  56.11)  ***½/T½

There Oughta Be a Law
Before All of This
Unfinished Business in London Town
Western Eyes
The Lonely Ones (1)
Rider (the Heartless Mare)
Finally Getting Over You
Let the Young Girl Do What She Wants to
The Nicest Kind of Lie
Lovers at the End of Time
Picture of the Moon
The New Me
Keeping Your Love Alive
The Lonely Ones (2)

Current availability:

Mellotrons used:

Liverpudlian (and proud of it!) Ian McNabb was the mainman of '80s jangly popsters The Icicle Works, who always had more depth to their sound that they were given credit for. His second solo album, 1994's Head Like a Rock, was notable for containing several tracks recorded with the incomparable Crazy Horse, although they only exacerbated McNabb's Neil Young comparisons. After '96's excellently-titled Merseybeast, his fourth effort was the largely acoustic (deep breath) A Party Political Broadcast on Behalf of the Emotional Party. I can see this one being something of a 'grower'; the songs are mostly heartfelt, with excellent lyrics and a refreshing lack of cynicism. I'll probably re-review this in a year, and give it a higher star rating. McNabb's credited with Mellotron on two tracks, with a regular string part on opener Sex With Someone You Love, with its ever-rising key changes, and also one of the small number of songs in the popular canon dealing with masturbation. You Only Get What You Deserve has more strings, but that's it, at least for this album.

Three years later, Ian McNabb, is, if anything, an improvement on its predecessor, with excellent, witty songwriting, viz Liverpool Girl or Rockin' For Jesus. The playing is more upfront than on A Party Political Broadcast..., with several tracks rocking out in grand style, with notable irony on Whatever It Takes, although McNabb's Neil Young fixation rears its slightly disfigured head again on Moment In The Sun. Difficult to work out exactly what is and isn't Mellotron here, as McNabb and drummer Geoff Dugmore both also play 'digital keyboard', but it sounds like 'Tron strings on (If We Believe) What Love Can Do, Open Air and Moment In The Sun, of which only the first is a typical ballad.

A collection of odds'n'sods from later the same year, Waifs & Strays, also features the Great White Beast; its contents range from '93 to 2000, and are pretty much all good enough to have made 'proper' album release (several are, in fact, 'work in progress' versions of tracks which ended up on McNabb's '90s albums). As with so many such projects, the tracks which aren't pre-production demos (Fire Inside My Soul, Loveless Age, several others) aren't sub-standard, just didn't quite fit onto the album for which they were recorded. There are some real gems here, not least the vocal and solo electric take on Head Like a Rock's Fire Inside My Soul, with no track making you think, "Wish they'd left that off...", even the generic blues, Not Lost Enough To Be Rescued. Mellotron on three tracks, with some really cranky single-note choir on Gak Mummy No.1 (cocaine/ancient Egypt reference), complete with outrageous key-click, strings on the balladic Why Are The Beautiful So Sad? and Nobody Say Nothin' To No One.

McNabb's 2005 release, Before All of This, is a single disc laid out as a double, split into 'acoustic' and 'electric' halves. The songwriting's as good as ever, although splitting the tracks this way might not work quite as well as integrating the styles. Best tracks? Maybe Western Eyes from the acoustic half (clever lyrics, too) and The Nicest Kind Of Lie from the electric camp. McNabb plays Mellotron on four tracks, with gentle strings on opener There Oughta Be A Law and The Lonely Ones (1), the latter also featuring McNabb's weird 'autotune vocals', a.k.a. how to gleefully misuse an expensive piece of studio gear. On the electric half, there's nothing audible on The Nicest Kind Of Lie, with more of those background strings on Picture Of The Moon, making for a fairly low-key Mellotron album.

So; A Party Political Broadcast... and Ian McNabb, are a cautious recommendation for those of you into singer-songwriter territory, but only the second is at all worth it for the 'Tron. Waifs & Strays and Before All of This are decent enough, with a handful of real gems on the former, but are unexciting Mellotronically.

Official site

Shannon McNally  (US)

Shannon McNally, 'Jukebox Sparrows'

Jukebox Sparrows  (2002, recorded 1997,  55.13)  ***/TT

Down and Dirty
I'll Always Be Around
Bitter Blue
Now That I Know
(It Ain't Easy Being) Green
It Could've Been Me

Bolder Than Paradise
Start All Over
Bury My Heart on the Jersey Shore
Jukebox Sparrows

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Shannon McNally recorded her first album, Jukebox Sparrows, in 1997, her charmless label then shelving it 'indefinitely'. Luckily for her, they finally decided to stick it out five years later, although it must have been a pretty dispiriting experience having relatively ancient material treated as if it were 'new'. It's not a bad album, in a roots-rock/alt.country vein, although several tracks slightly outstay their welcome and few really grab the listener by the throat yelling "Listen to me!", although the closing title track stands out by dint of sounding nothing like the rest of the record.

Ron Aniello is credited with Mellotron, although the ubiquitous Patrick Warren also turns up, merely credited with 'keyboards', making me wonder if he brought his Chamberlin along. Anyway, it sounds like tape-replay of some description on several tracks, with strings on Now That I Know, It Could've Been Me and Colorado, although it could be elsewhere, too, not least opener Down And Dirty. Overall, then, a fairly ordinary record, which may be why Capitol shelved it originally, although I've heard an awful lot worse in a similar style. Three reasonable 'Tron tracks, although not enough to get too hot under the collar about.

Official site

Machiavel  (Belgium)

Machiavel, 'Jester'

Jester  (1977,  46.12/50.23)  ****/TTTT

Sparkling Jaw
In the Reign of Queen Pollution
The Jester
Mr. Street Fair
Rock, Sea and Tree
[CD adds:
The Birds Are Gone
I'm Nowhere]
Machiavel, 'Mechanical Moonbeams'

Mechanical Moonbeams  (1978,  41.44/53.39)  ****½/TTTT

Beyond the Silence
Summon Up Your Strength
Rope Dancer
After the Crop

The Fifth Season
[CD adds:
Wind of Life
I'm Not a Loser]
Machiavel, 'Urban Games'

Urban Games  (1979,  37.01/43.27)  ***/TT½

The Humans
Over the Hill
Still Alive
City Flowers
Dancing Heroes
I'm Not a Loser
Let Me Live My Life
The Dictators
[CD adds:
Over the Hill (remix)
King of Slogans]

Current availability:

Mellotrons used:

A few years ago, my mate Danny persuaded me to accompany him on an insane overnight trip to Belgium to see the reformed Machiavel, featuring Danny's friend and Now keyboard player Hervé Borbé. I really didn't know what to expect (this was my first trip across the Channel to catch a gig. But not my last...), but they were magnificent. Despite playing some pretty awful later material, they opened their set with the massed synths of Wisdom from Jester, and proceeded to play many other numbers from the band's first three albums. So, what was all the fuss about? Why get four hours' sleep in 48 to see a band almost no-one outside Belgium has ever heard of?

Albert Letecheur, Mellotron just about visible

I'd bought a reduced copy of Jester a year or so earlier as an experiment, and was instantly captivated. Machiavel's strange mixture of Genesis, Yes and Supertramp is actually quite unique, although it sounds only partly-formed on '76's Machiavel, despite some decent material. Keyboard man Albert Letecheur obtained a Mellotron before recording began on the following year's Jester, which put them into a whole different league. I don't know if they ever really played abroad, but I'm sure they could've broken out of Belgium with some hard work and a little luck. Mind you, '77 in Britain wasn't the best year for prog...

On Jester, Machiavel found the elusive quality that escapes so many bands: Their Own Voice. The influences mentioned above are just that; influences. The Supertramp comparison (not one that many bands would clamour for) is evident only in Letecheur's percussive electric piano, his chief instrument, but his synth and Mellotron work show how individual his style had become. There isn't a duff track on the album, with particular highlights being Wisdom and The Jester, with its scintillating Moog part. Most of the 'Tron use is on the choir front, although Moments gives the strings a rare outing (Letecheur mostly used string synth, for some reason), but the album's strengths are in its songwriting and arrangements rather than the Mellotron parts.

1978's Mechanical Moonbeams is, if anything, even better, although the first hints of their later mainstream style can be heard creeping through some of the arrangements, particularly with regard to Jean Paul Devaux's more upfront guitar parts. This is still superbly symphonic progressive, however, just with more rhythm guitar than many bands utilised. The material is almost universally excellent, with particular highlights being Rope Dancer, The Fifth Season and one of their best-loved songs, After The Crop. Again, most of the Mellotron work is choirs, although there's a string part in The Fifth Season; good all round, very atmospheric, very tasteful, although there is one 'Tron oddity on the album. After The Crop features, at around the five-minute mark, what has to be the only example of 'boogie 'Tron choir' ever. This quite defies description, to be honest; hear it and marvel! Although excellent, it's indicative of the direction the band would head in before long, but don't let that put you off. The CD has one 'Tron bonus track, too, in Wind Of Life; more choirs, usual stuff. Top marks, incidentally, for the bizarre artwork on these two albums, although I'm not entirely sure how they got away with the inside gatefold of Jester...

In retrospect, I suppose it's quite amazing that Machiavel put out a prog classic as late as 1978, so it's no surprise at all that '79's Urban Games is something of a letdown, although the following year's New Lines is much worse. Mainstream rock with progressive bits in places, Urban Games is generally one for the prog fan to avoid, to be honest, although it tends towards 'low side of average' rather than 'complete rubbish'; imagine a much less progressive version of their previous sound and you're probably somewhere near. Opener Humans, City Flowers and The Dictators are the best things here, although they pale in comparison to the best material from Mechanical Moonbeams. Letecheur (on his last album with the band) still gets some 'Tron choir onto most tracks (Humans/City Flowers/I'm Not a Loser/Let Me Live My Life/The Dictators, plus King Of Slogans, on the CD version), but it's mostly rather uninspiring stuff.

So; buy Jester and Mechanical Moonbeams immediately. Two superb albums, with excellent Mellotron work to boot. Machiavel's also worth hearing, but apart from a recent-ish live album, er, Live, from the period when I saw the band, give everything else a miss. It would be nice if any contemporaneous live recordings crept out, but don't hold your breath.

Official site

The Machine  (Netherlands)  see: Samples

Machine & the Synergetic Nuts  (Japan)

Machine & the Synergetic Nuts, 'Leap Second Neutral'

Leap Second Neutral  (2005,  54.21)  ***½/T

Solid Box

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Machine & the Synergetic Nuts are a Japanese fusion outfit who, at least on their second album, 2005's Leap Second Neutral, play a style that veers between the rather generic and the genuinely progressive, not entirely unlike Yes' fusion flirtations on Relayer. Highlights? The piano chording on Trout is particularly effective, as is the vaguely Crimsonesque opening to Texas, although material such as Neutral and Oz are a little too 'fusion by numbers' for their own good.

Iwata Noriya plays almost certainly real Mellotron, with a brief, wobbly string part on Texas and a flute line and exceedingly wobbly strings on closer Normal, clearly meant to sound as unstable as they do. You'll need a reasonable tolerance for fusion in order to get much out of this, but its progressive influences, rather than its minor Mellotron use, make it worth the effort.

Official record company site

Machines of Loving Grace  (US)

Machines of Loving Grace, 'Gilt'

Gilt  (1995,  42.56)  **½/TT

Richest Junkie Still Alive
Kiss Destroyer
Suicide King

Animal Mass
The Soft Collision
Solar Temple
Casual Users
Twofold Godhead

Current availability:

Chamberlin used:

Machines of Loving Grace operated in the 'industrial' demi-monde; that is, beat-heavy '90s metal with the odd sample thrown in, not SPK-style road-drills-on-stage industrial. Not 'industrial' at all, really, is it? 1995's Gilt was their third and last album, the cover shot tastefully based on an infamous '40s picture of a suicide victim. Nice. The music's everything you'd expect and less, with all the usual Nine Inch Nails clichés, all seeming strangely lifeless on cold plastic; I'm sure you had to see this lot live for it to make any real sense.

Mike Fisher plays Chamberlin on several tracks, with string parts on Kiss Destroyer (GREAT title!), Suicide King, The Soft Collision and a few seconds at the end of Tryst, though not obviously on closer Serpico, one of two tracks I was led to believe did have some. Anyway, unexpectedly heavy use on a rather dullsville album, so let's not look the proverbial gift horse, eh?

Fan site

Mad Men & English Dogs  (UK)  see: Samples

Mad Scene  (New Zealand/US)

Mad Scene, 'Sealight'

Sealight  (1995,  53.09)  **½/T

Strange to Be Here
Transatlantic Telephone Conversation
Gotta Get Back (to Something)
Here Goes Nothing
Black Flye
Marching Song
Birthday Party
Spilled Oranges
You Wear Funny Clothes
My Dreams Are Losing Their Teeth

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

New Zealanders Mad Scene (originally Monsterlight) moved to New York in 1991, releasing their debut EP, Falling Over: Spilling Over the following year. After '93's A Trip Thru Monsterland, it took them two years to produce the sort-of psychedelic Sealight, which turned out to be their last album, although they put a couple more EPs out before they folded. Sealight's one of those 'yeah, it's OK' kind of albums that has more ambition than actual talent, or so it sounds to me, although the band contained members of such Antipodean luminaries as the Go-Betweens and The Clean. West Coast heroes Love are an obvious influence, particularly the trumpet work, but the songs seem to be missing, or maybe I'm just not hearing them. Also, like so many other albums of its type, it's too long. Just because you CAN fit lots of music on a CD doesn't mean you HAVE to, OK?

Mellotron from Dean Falcone, with flutes and strings on opener Strange To Be Here and slightly skronky string and choir parts on My Dreams Are Losing Their Teeth, though hardly enough to make a purchase worthwhile. I hate to shoot well-meaning efforts down in flames, but this is a 15-track, 53-minute album, and I was bored after about track 8. Sorry.

The Mad Trist  (Netherlands)

The Mad Trist, 'Animals & Acrobats'

Animals & Acrobats  (2013,  46.09)  **½/TT

Lack of Light
Pie in the Sky
The Witness
No Survivors
Is That a Sin?

Common Sense
The Pleasure is Mine
A Policy
Time is on My Side
Animals & Acrobats

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

2013's Animals & Acrobats is Dutch outfit Mad Trist's second album, an indie/alt.rock hybrid, apparently vaguely comparable to the Queens of the Stone Age in places, although I'll admit I can't hear the comparison. What I can hear is '90s alt.rock with a dash of U2's Gloria on opener Lack Of Light, electronica-influenced indie on Pie In The Sky, goth on Is That A Sin? and even post-rock, on the closing title track, amongst other, rather disparate influences.

Ruud Peeters (Daniel Versteegh) plays his own M400 on the album, with a brief background string line on No Survivors, a more upfront part (with cellos) on Is That A Sin?, a high string note in Serenades sustained for so long that studio trickery must be involved and a more varied part in Time Is On My Side. Can I recommend this? Honestly? No.

Official site

Madden & Harris  (Australia)

Madden & Harris, 'Fools Paradise'

Fools Paradise  (1975,  42.29/48.47)  ****/TTT½

Fools Paradise Part 2
The Wind at Eve
Margaret O'Grady

I Heard a Man Say
O'Weary Brain
Cool September
Fool's Paradise
  Children of Ice
  Will You Be There
  End Game

[CD adds:
Remember Me
A Simple Song

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Sydney-based Dave Madden and Peter Harris (Madden was Harris' guitar student) have remained completely underneath the prog radar until recently, when their sole album, Fools Paradise [sic.], was reissued on the Korean M2U label. The duo had released a single, Remember Me, in 1974, releasing the album the following year, in a pressing rumoured to be only a few hundred copies. It's a lovely piece of folk/prog, largely consisting of gentle acoustic numbers like The Wind At Eve or I Heard A Man Say, with the only real blip being O'Weary Brain, a jaunty, piano-led song, slightly out of place with the gentle melancholy of most of the other tracks.

Multi-instrumentalist Harris played all the album's keyboards, including Mellotron on a few tracks. There's a beautiful string part on opener Wishes, with a more background one on The Wind At Eve, before something very interesting (well, I thought so) on Margaret O'Grady: male voices in the background, revealing themselves to be Mellotronically-generated at one point. However, this isn't your standard 8-choir, or even the standalone male voices; it has far more of the sound of the infamously not-very-good 16-voice Teddy Taylor, or 'TT' choir. Which Australian Mellotron-owning band had the TT choir? The also Sydney-based Sebastian Hardie, that's who. I can't prove it, but... Anyway, more of those voices on part three of the side-long title track, E.I.E.I.O, and another upfront string part on the closing section, End Game. Maybe surprisingly, the CD's bonus tracks (both sides of the single) also feature Harris on 'Tron strings, and as you're exceedingly unlikely to find the original vinyl, I'll include them in the album's 'T' rating.

All in all, a very good album indeed; top marks to M2U for resurrecting this obscurity and making it available to the sort of audience it should've had first time round. This just proves that, like Quarteto 1111's criminally still-unreissued Onde Quando..., there are almost certainly many classic Mellotron Albums from the machine's heyday out there still waiting to be rediscovered, even if this one 'only' features it on five tracks. This is decidedly worth picking up, though probably more for the music than the 'Tron, though the latter certainly isn't to be sniffed at. Recommended.

Made in Sweden  (Sweden)

Made in Sweden, 'Made in England'

Made in England  (1970,  39.03)  ***/T

Winter's a Bummer
You Can't Go Home
Mad River
Chicago, Mon Amour
Love Samba
Blind Willie
Little Cloud

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Made in Sweden can probably be considered that country's first genuinely 'progressive' group, although Made in England (a.k.a. Mad River) was actually their fourth album in three years, and the first to head in a progressive direction. Saying that, it's more late-period psych than anything, with various influences popping up here and there (notably the jazz/blues of Blind Willie) and I have to admit I don't find it as riveting as some online reviewers, although it's by no means bad. The first few tracks are probably the best, before the band heads off into various musical cul-de-sacs and loses its way slightly.

Bassist Bo Häggström doubles on piano and Mellotron (guitarist/vocalist/main man George Wadenius also doubles on piano and organ), although there's only one 'Tron track here, with some great MkII strings/brass mix pitchbend work on jazzy opener Winter's A Bummer. The upshot of this is; Swedish proto-prog, well-played, not much Mellotron. Your choice.

Madison Dyke  (Germany)

Madison Dyke, 'Zeitmaschine

Zeitmaschine  (1977,  36.53)  ***½/0

First Step
Cooking Time of an Egg
Next Conceptions

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

What appears to be Madison Dyke's sole release, Zeitmaschine (Time Machine, of course), is a bit of a mish-mash of styles, veering between hard rock, prog and ambient German stuff, often within the same track. It's difficult to pick out any one track as particularly superior to any other, although the side-long title track may just have the edge over the rest, with some nice flute work from vocalist Burkard Rittler. Actually, a passable comparison, at least in their more drifting moments, would be Novalis, although they're by no means a clone.

Now, both Rittler and guitarist Jürgen Baumann are credited with 'Mellotron', but all I can hear is swathes of string synth; the only thing that stops me dumping the album straight into Mistaken ID is the two credited players. Maybe it's just buried in the mix? Maybe they had some custom string synth tapes made up? Maybe they thought it would sell more records to prog fans?

Anyway, not a bad album, though a bit run-of-the-mill in places, but bugger-all 'Tron, at least to my ears.

Madness  (UK)

, 'Can't Touch Us Now'

Can't Touch Us Now  (2016,  59.15)  ***½/T½

Can't Touch Us Now
Good Times
Mr. Apples
I Believe
You Are My Everything
Another Version of Me
Mumbo Jumbo
Don't Leave the Past Behind You
(Don't Let Them) Catch You Crying
Pam the Hawk
Given the Opportunity
Soul Denying
Whistle in the Dark

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

In the generally-quite-nice north London street where I grew up, there was one 'problem' family, living some doors down on the other side, a younger son of whom would menace me occasionally. Imagine my surprise when I discovered Madness' Cathal (a.k.a. Carl) "Chas Smash" Smyth was his elder brother... Sadly, it did nothing to endear the band to me; the suits/short hair/danceable music combo shared by the era's crapulent 'mod revival' and the Two Tone crowd was enough to bring a young Rock Geezer out in hives. Age has, of course (?), brought wisdom, not to mention a belated appreciation of Madness' superb, über-north-London thang; seriously, how can anyone take offence at their jaw-dropping run of hits? I'd go as far as to say that there appears to be a Madness-shaped hole in my collection in dire need of filling.

2016's Can't Touch Us Now is their tenth album (bear in mind that they disappeared for a decade) and, although I'll admit to having heard none of its predecessors, must surely stand up against them for the sheer quality of its songwriting. Highlights? The opening title track, both singles (Mr. Apples and the reggae-inflected Herbert) and Don't Leave The Past Behind You, with its simple-yet-effective piano riff, amongst many others. Criticisms? Given that we're talking about a band known for their singles, the whole affair is a little overlong and could possibly be improved by the removal of some of its more ordinary material (Grand Slam, Another Version Of Me, Mumbo Jumbo). Saying that, even the more musically mundane tracks tend to be lyrically worthwhile, so what do I know?

As with so many of my Mellotron hire jobs, this one began with a call from Liam 'Toe Rag Studios' Watson. "So who's it for this time, Liam?" "Madness." "Oh!" Well, what do you say? My M400's been used by a few unlikely artists, but Madness? As it turns out, although I was expecting to meet Mike Barson, it was played by guitarist Chris "Chrissy Boy" Foreman, who adds typically clunky vibes to Blackbird, upfront flutes to the excellent, reggae-inflected Herbert and background flutes to Soul Denying, only really audible at the end. It's entirely possible that it crops up elsewhere, but, given the real strings used on several tracks, it's difficult to say for sure. Incidentally, my thanks to legendary producer Clive Langer who, unannounced, helped me carry The Beast down the long corridor to the studio. A lovely, unassuming man.

Unsurprisingly, I'd never seen the band live before, so was delighted to see that they were headlining one night at this year's Fairport Convention's annual Cropredy bash (at which I'm a regular attendee). Bizarrely, three or four bands lower down the bill were the superb Gryphon. Bizarrely, other than the stylistic clash? I've now succeeded in seeing, on the same bill, the band who originally owned my Mellotron and its latest users. Weird. And Chas' younger brother? Brendan (co-writer of a brief number on the band's debut) was last heard of suing a Madness tribute act for using 'his' walk (you known the one) that he claims to've created in the band's early days. His lawyer commented, "Unfortunately, Brendan had some difficulties with the band during their heyday and never really benefited financially as he should have done." Read that as you will.

Official site

Madnomad  (UK)

Madnomad, 'Tamper-Evident'

Tamper-Evident  (2003,  42.10)  **½/T

Direct Evidence Against Uniqueness
It is This
Ad Nauseum
Tamper Evident
Let's Kill the Pig
Love is Sometimes Colder Than Ice
The Drunkard's Song
35 Summers
2 Peter 2:22
Longest Road
Gun of Sod

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Bristol's Madnomad mix techno, metal, pop and just about anything else you can think of into a huge smörgåsbord of, er, something or other on 2003's Tamper-Evident. Does it work? Depends on your point of view, I suppose. I'd imagine they are (or were) the dog's bollocks live, but come across as slightly sterile on record, sometimes sounding like a thirteen-band compilation rather than a cohesive document of the band's sound. The sleeve design is based around food packaging, including an ingredients list, which puts Matt Sampson's Mellotron at the bottom, with '1%', alongside 'banjo' and 'child'. What you actually get is a flute melody on Direct Evidence Against Uniqueness and what sounds like string section on Love Is Sometimes Colder Than Ice, although I wouldn't swear blind to the latter.

Overall, then, one of those current 'we do everything' type of albums that's not only difficult to categorise (usually a good thing), but difficult to get any sort on handle on, too (a less good thing). Either way, very little Mellotron (real or otherwise), so really not worth it on that front. Incidentally, the demise of the band's domain name makes me think they've probably been consigned to the dustbin of history.

Madonna  (US)

Madonna, 'Beautiful Stranger' CDS  (1999,  18.40)  **½/T½

Beautiful Stranger

Beautiful Stranger (Calderone Club Mix)
Beautiful Stranger (Calderone Radio Mix)

Current availability:

Chamberlin used:

The quite remarkably talent-free Maddy recorded this lightweight piece of fluff for the second Austin Powers film, with the production assistance of the extraordinarily fashionable William Orbit, I believe. Along with the upbeat melody, it's got an irritating synth hook which she echoes in that appalling nasal whine she does so well. You may have guessed that I'm not her biggest fan, but I approached this with a (relatively) open mind, and was comprehensively defeated.

I'm told the flutes are from a Chamberlin; they certainly sound like some form of tape replay, but I've no idea who plays it, even if it's genuine. Orbit? Anyway, nice warbly flutes wandering in and out of the song, quite upfront in the mix, which makes a change, but I wouldn't go out to buy it on those grounds, if I were you.

Official site

Madrigal  (UK)

Madrigal, 'Beneath the Greenwood Tree'

Beneath the Greenwood Tree  (1973,  32.23)  ***/½

Madrigal Theme
Marvellous Clouds
Long a-Growing
Mammy Blue
Sounds of Silence
Bye Bye Love
The Greenwood Tree
One Misty Moisty Morning
Trains & Boats & Planes
Christmas Lullaby
(Take Me Home) Country Roads
Watch the Changing Faces
April Come She Will
California Dreaming

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Madrigal (as against any other band of the same name) were a nine-piece British folk outfit that coalesced from two other groups, specialising in massed male and female harmony/unison vocals with minimal instrumentation. While most of the material is traditional (Steeleye Span tackled One Misty Moisty Morning), several covers creep in, including Simon & Garfunkel's The Sounds Of Silence, The Everly Brothers' Bye Bye Love, Burt Bacharach's Trains And Boats And Planes, John Denver's (Take Me Home) Country Roads and The Mamas & the Papas' immortal California Dreaming. Stylistically, the album's a bit of an acquired taste, being rather too church choir/easy listening for many folk fans, although it's far from offensive, just lacking in personality.

Carolyn Whettell plays Mellotron, although the only definite parts are the flute line and cello on closer California Dreaming, presumably on a studio machine. Given that this is easily available as a download (you really are not going to find an original - a mere hundred were pressed), you can hear it without having to splash out, although if it's Mellotron you're after, you're probably best off going elsewhere.

Madrigal  (France)

Madrigal, 'School of Time'

School of Time  (1977,  39.54)  ***½/T

The Seeker
King's Dynasty
Across the Past
The Old Clock
School of Time
The Ghost
Dear Mister Fantasy

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Madrigal's School of Time is a bit of an oddball release, to be honest; after the hard-rock-with-clever-bits of The Seeker, hearing anything especially progressive seems unlikely. However, Mad opens with an intricate vocal arrangement, adding keyboards to the mix, while King's Dynasty rips Queen off something rotten, notably the Killer Queen cop on the chorus. Vocals are in (accented) English throughout, which is rare for a French band, so they must have had one eye on the international market, for all the good it did them. The rest of the album carries on in similar vein, switching between styles in what is actually a rather refreshing manner, given how genre-specific most bands are these days.

Next to no Mellotron, to be honest, with a fairly full-on choir part on Across The Past, with strings sounding like a 'Tron/string synth mix. More string synth and real flute on The Old Clock, but that seems to be it on the 'Tron front. Yet again, you're not going to find this that easily, although copies do crop up on various sites, not least eBay. Do you want it? Well, how badly do you need a 'not bad, not great' semi-progressive late-'70s French album? It's an interesting listen in places, certainly, but one for the hardcore proghead only, I think.

Madrugada  (Norway)

Madrugada, 'The Deep End'

The Deep End  (2005,  59.41/66.23)  ***/½

The Kids Are on High Street
On Your Side
Hold on to You
Stories From the Streets
Running Out of Time
The Lost Gospel
Elektro Vakuum
Subterranean Sunlight
Hard to Come Back
Slow Builder
Sail Away
[Bonus tracks:
Life in the City
I'm in Love]

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Madrugada have been described as Norway's answer to R.E.M., although to my ears, they sound more like a cross between Neil Young and a better version of, say, Counting Crows, at least on their fourth album, 2005's The Deep End. While not a bad album as such, it outstays its welcome by several tracks, sounding a bit anodyne compared to many American bands playing in a similar style.

Kevin Savigar plays Mellotron flutes on regular album closer Sail Away, mixed in with his B3 and Wurly, to the point where they're only fully audible occasionally, all of which adds up to: passable but unexciting with very little Mellotron. The band subsequently split, following guitarist Robert Burås' untimely death in 2007, finishing their last album and playing a farewell tour in his honour.

Official site

See: Sivert Höyem

Màelstrom  (US)

Màelstrom, 'Màelstrom'

On the Gulf  [a.k.a. Màelstrom]  (1973,  37.03/50.10)  ***½/TTTT

In Memory
The Balloonist
Law and Crime
Nature Abounds
Below the Line
[CD adds:
Opus None
Genesis to Geneva]

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Add Màelstrom to the ever-expanding list of obscure US prog outfits who never got anywhere, despite being rather good. I believe On the Gulf did actually gain a release at the time, unlike many of their contemporaries' recordings, but it had disappeared into the mists of time until recent CD reissue as Màelstrom (hooray!). The band's sound actually owed quite a bit to The Moody Blues in places, who I believe were absolutely massive in the States in the early '70s. Saying that, there are traces of ELP here and there, not to mention the more 'generic' progressive sound prevalent at the time. The band were never destined to be frontrunners, to be honest, although Màelstrom is a decidedly worthy effort, if not exactly the next Yes.

The Mellotron was played by both Roberts Owen and Mark Knox, and it has to be said, they used it to rather delightful excess, with only In Memory escaping. As you'd expect, most of their use is in the strings area, although the odd burst of choir here and there makes a nice change, especially for the time, and there may be some cellos, too. The album does sound a bit dated for the time, to be honest, but it's worth a listen for the music, and definitely for the 'Tron. Incidentally, the CD's two live bonus tracks are from 1980, with one D. Kent Overholser on unusually late use of Mellotron on Opus None.

Maestoso  (UK)  see:


Lois Maffeo & Brendan Canty  (US)

Lois Maffeo & Brendan Canty, 'The Union Themes'

The Union Themes  (2000,  31.04)  ***/T

These Parts
Being Blind
How I Came to Know
Best Believe
You Love Your Wounds
Hollow Reed
Give Faith
Con Job

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Lois Maffeo has been around since the late '80s; amusingly, an early band was called Courtney Love, after a certain housemate of hers (!). Although she has spent much of her time in the '90s on her Lois project, The Union Themes is a collaboration with Fugazi drummer Brendan Canty, and is a gentle, acoustic singer-songwriter album. I have to admit I'm not blown away by it, though I suspect the deficiency is in myself, not Lois. I'm sure it does what it does very well; it just doesn't click with my personal taste in this area.

Lois sings and plays acoustic guitar and flute, with Canty covering most of the rest of the instrumental spectrum, including Mellotron. Sadly, it's only to be heard on one track, with a little orchestrally-arranged string part in the middle of Being Blind, making a whole T slightly generous, to be honest. It's difficult to recommend this album to fans of 'standard' singer-songwriter fare, but some of you are going to go for it. Not worth it for the 'Tron input, though.

Maga  (Spain)

Maga, 'Maga'

Maga  (2006,  41.23)  **/0

Al Dictado
Dardo y Alicia
El Cristal por Dentro
Pasó el Cometa
Año Nuevo
Mi Casa de Pájaros
Trampa en la Boca
La Otra Mitad
Nada Nuevo Bajo el Sol

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

Maga are a Spanish pop/rock outfit who have elected, for reasons known only to themselves, to self-title their first three albums. Aping Peter Gabriel? In that only, I can assure you. Anyway, 2006's Maga is their third release of that name, a thoroughly average effort aimed at the local market, although I can't imagine these songs doing well internationally with English lyrics, but then, what do I know?

Jordi Gil is credited with 'programming, Solina and Mellotron' on several tracks, none specified Mellotronically. As it happens, it's inaudible on all of them, so God alone knows whether he actually used a real one or not and if so, where. Did you need another excuse not to hear this album? You've got one.


Magenta  (UK)  see: Samples

Magenta  (Norway)  see: Samples

Magic Numbers  (UK)

Magic Numbers, 'Undecided'

Undecided  (2007,  24.59)  **½/T

Fear of Sleep
The Shooter
Let Somebody in (alt.version)
Sissy and the Silent Kid
Magic Numbers, 'The Runaway'

The Runaway  (2010,  54.14/72.32)  *½/T

The Pulse
Hurt So Good
Why Did You Call?
Once I Had
A Start With No Ending
Throwing My Heart Away
Restless River
Only Seventeen
Sound of Something
The Song That No One Knows
Dreams of a Revelation
I'm Sorry
2-disc ed. adds:
Hurt So Good (live)
Why Did You Call? (live)
Restless River (live)
Dreams of a Revelation (live)

Current availability:

Mellotron used:

The double brother/sister foursome The Magic Numbers seem to've captured critics' collective imaginations, although their 2007 EP, Undecided, gives me few clues as to why. A couple of its limp tracks aren't so bad, but six on the trot is enough to make my teeth squeak. Romeo Stodart plays Mellotron strings on closer Sissy And The Silent Kid, one of the aforementioned better tracks, but I'm not at all convinced it's real.

Listening to their third album, 2010's The Runaway, I have absolutely no idea why anyone likes this band. None. None at all. Remember soft rock? This is the same (lack of) style, updated for a new (and not obviously better) millennium, pathetically excused by said critics as 'folk influenced'. Well, if this is folk, I'm the proverbial denizen of the Orient; if it looks like soft rock and sounds like soft rock, then soft rock it bloody well is and a pretty poor example of it, to boot. Michele Stodart plays what might very well be real Mellotron on Dreams Of A Revelation, with strings under real ones and a faint flute part, none of which really improves the album in any meaningful way.

Christ, is this what we've come to? A bunch of hairy musicians who look like they might at least do something interesting, then don't? Drivel.

Official site

previous pagenext page