Built to Spill
|7" (1970) ***/TT½
King of Fuh
Extemporaneous (1969, 45.15/58.43) *½/T
I Love to Hear a Baby Cry/King of Fuh
And Now, as We Get Serious/Astronauts/Dockin'
Commercial: Surfer Sam/Subway Lines
The Sirens Cry/The Gun/W.A.R./Bearer of Somber News
The Big Burp Theory/Six Interrogatives of Existence
Five Minutes for Peace
Dwayne of the Upper Regions/Schma/The Lord is One
Growth of Hair/Hail the Hare/Now You're Gettin' the
I Like to Drink Honey/The Hexagon/The Beauty of
Nutty, Fragrant Something to See/I Want to Say
'Peace on Earth'
Don't Paranoi it, Enjoy it/The Reds Are Yellow/Thank
Tapeworm of Love (alternate version)
King of Fuh (single version)
Nobody Knows What's Goin' on in My Mind But Me
Brute Force was a pseudonym for New Yorker Stephen Friedland, rather than a band proper, although I'm filing them/him under 'B' rather than 'F'. Friedland apparently now slightly regrets taking a pseudonym, although it's better than his original 'Krude Brute'. Anyway, he managed to get a tape of King Of Fuh to a Beatles associate, who played it to George Harrison, who loved it; George tried to get it released on EMI, but when they declined, George had it privately pressed in a small run, available only via mail order (and later privately released by Friedland himself). Why did EMI decline? Well, you've probably pronounced the title as 'foo'. Wrong. Try 'uh' as in 'but', or 'gun'. Or indeed, 'fuck'. Try the chorus for size:
|'And the Fuh King did what he wanted to do,
The Fuh King went where he wanted to go,
Mighty, mighty Fuh King,
All hail the Fuh King'.
Friedland explains it thus:
|I didn't accept the censorship and language taboo, and sought to open the mass megalithic mind even a millimeter more. Yet the same entrenched fear was inside the mind and hearts of the radio program managers, a fear not of the melody, more with the lyrics (although the lyrics have nothing to do with sex, only with the Beauty of the world, and Individuality), but the awesome fear which grips a human being upon looking at the sky and envisioning one's place in the universe, and also the fear of leaving one's pigeonhole job and standing in the unemployment line.|
Yes, Stephen. Or maybe it was simply a juvenile attempt to get the work 'fucking' onto the radio. it's a shame, actually, as the song's a pretty good Beatlesesque psych-pop number, although the lyrics scan abominably, even when Friedland wasn't trying to get around the 'censorship and language taboo'. It's also layered in Mark II 'Tron strings and has a neat major-to-minor shift after the chorus. It was, of course, consigned to almost immediate obscurity, although it's now finally easily available as a bonus track on Brute Force's Tour De Brute Force, released in 2001. I've no idea if there's any more Mellotron on any of Friedland's work, and although King Of Fuh is in some ways a nice track, the infantile lyrics tend to rather put me off. Pity.
Stop press: The track's also available on the CD edition of Friedland's second album, Extemporaneous, from 1970. The album's basically a recording of his live cabaret show, in front of a small invited audience in New York. It's terrible, as you might've guessed, but at least you can get hold of King Of Fuh fairly easily now, should you wish to. Oh, and World manages to repeat the word 'bullshit' about 987 times [yawn].
Journey (1979, 43.36) ***/TTTJourney
I Know the Time
Buccheri specialised in a rather un-Italian form of electronic music, and I'm afraid to say he was never going to be one of the genre's front-runners. It's not that Journey is bad, exactly, just that it isn't particularly good, either. The side-long title track is rather bitty and disjointed, sounding more like several shorter tracks nailed together in a rather unharmonious way than one cohesive piece, and much of the side two material doesn't really stand up, especially Jesus Christ, a rather poor attempt at a 'proper song'. There are other musicians on the album, including a drummer who crops up here and there, and although he's not credited as such, I presume the occasional vocals are by Buccheri too (both are present and incorrect on the final track).
Sorry to be so harsh, but I've heard a great deal better in this area, and my listening pleasure wasn't particularly enhanced by such a dodgy transfer to CD that at several points, it sounds like the tape slipped, or even that it was transferred from a vinyl copy with an off-centre hole. Anyway, Buccheri's Mellotron work seems to be exclusively choir, usually mixed with string synth, with a strong presence on every track except Solitude. Saying that, it's mostly quite background work, and decidedly unambitious, leaving the album with only three Ts.
So, one for EM fanatics only, I think, although I know full well that there's an awful lot worse about than this. Lots of 'Tron, but it's neither upfront, varied or doing anything very interesting, so I believe the choice is yours.
Pat Buchanan (2003, 34.46) ***/T
Smile on My Face
The World is Flat
Under the Sun
Love Goes Up in Smoke
Insects and Angels
The Longest Day
Don't Forget to Write
Pat Buchanan writes McCartneyesque pop in the grand tradition on his eponymous debut (?), sometimes slipping into a 1940s groove, not least on opener You Lose and the strings-laden Glass. Highlights? Luckiest Girl, Under The Sun, the propulsive Love Goes Up In Smoke and sentimental closer Don't Forget To Write, maybe.
Brad Jones plays what sounds like real Chamberlin, with background flutes on You Lose, one of the brass variants (and strings?) on The World Is Flat and upfront strings on Under The Sun, although the strings on Glass sound real. But is You Lose based on a rhythm tape from one of the earlier machines, I wonder? Difficult to say, without knowing much about Chamberlin rhythm tapes. One for Macca fans, then.
Incredibly out of date official site
Rescue Me (1974, 34.11) ***½/TRescue Me
I'm the Ram
In the Beginning
You're Killing My Love
She Can't Say No
Roy Buchanan is one of those tremendous guitarists whose appeal has never really exceeded 'cult' status; after his earlyish death in 1988, at the age of 48, he's unlikely to now, sadly. His fourth solo album, 1974's Rescue Me, consists of his usual brew of soul and blues, concentrating on the latter, all infused with his truly exceptional Telecaster tone (we're talking about the man who effectively invented the 'pinched harmonic' here). If you're of a 'prog or die' disposition, you're probably not going to like this very much, but it does what it does perfectly, better tracks (at least to my ears) including In The Beginning and the slow, mournful blues of Wayfairing Pilgrim [sic] that closes the record.
Although Ken Freeman, inventor of the Freeman String Symphonizer, one of the first (the first?) string machines, is credited with keyboards, he plays Mellotron on Wayfairing Pilgrim to good effect. This isn't an album for the Mellotron obsessive, but its sole 'Tron track is worth hearing if you're going to buy the album anyway. Incidentally, thanks to Tilo for making me aware of its Mellotronic credentials.
Mercurotones (1990, 40.06) ***½/T
Five o'Clock or Thursday (Up to You)
Avenue F Blues
Ready to Break
Brother (Take These Dreams)
Popular wisdom has it that Texans The Buck Pets were a few years too early for their own good; who'd be an innovator, eh? They were playing 'alternative rock' in the late '80s, but weren't picked up on when it broke worldwide in the early '90s, by which time they were disintegrating. The usual influences they're assigned include Hüsker Dü and The Replacements, the same bands that were being quoted not so long after by Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Stone Temple Pilots et al., although I have to say that their second album, 1990's Mercurotones, is far more appealing than anything I've heard by any of those bands bar Nirvana, who were in a different league anyway. Best tracks? Probably the acoustic Some Hesitation, Five O'Clock Or Thursday (Up To You) and the cello-driven Ready To Break, but there's nothing here that either bored or offended me, which is quite a trick in itself.
Someone plays Mellotron on a couple of tracks, the most likely candidate being producer and M400 owner Michael Beinhorn (Liquid Jesus, Soundgarden, Chili Peppers etc.etc.), with a string part on Five O'Clock Or Thursday (Up To You) and less of the same on Brother (Take These Dreams). So; a formative kind of '90s album before the '90s had really got going, with plenty of energy and a little Mellotron. Could be a lot worse. Oh, and their frontman is my namesake (albeit preferring Andrew), the first time I've come across another one on this site.
(Semi-?) official site
Sketches for My Sweetheart the Drunk (1998, recorded 1992-97, 97.32) ****/T
|Sky is a Landfill
Everybody Here Wants You
Nightmares By the Sea
Yard of Blonde Girls
New Year's Prayer
You & I
Nightmares By the Sea
New Year's Prayer
Haven't You Heard
I Know We Could Be So Happy Baby
(if We Wanted to Be)
Murder Suicide Meteor Slave
|Back in N.Y.C.
Your Flesh is So Nice
You'll all know the tragic Jeff Buckley story, of course; son of Tim, but barely knew him, released classic debut Grace (****½), died idiotically before putting out a follow-up. What a waste. Well, if Sketches for My Sweetheart the Drunk (he'd stated that his second album would be titled My Sweetheart the Drunk) is 'merely' a bunch of demos and outtakes... The guy had talent by the bucketload, and should've had a long and honourable career, not blown it by drowning in a Mississippi tributary fifty years before his time. Sketches... isn't all great, by any means, but there's more good material here than on many far more established artists' regular albums. I'll leave it to others, more tuned into what he was doing, to review this properly, just to say that if you're into songs, as against excuses for a tune, you won't go too far wrong here.
I'm not 100% sure exactly how many tracks feature the mighty 'Tron; there's absolutely no doubt about New Year's Prayer, with the unknown Mellotronist (Buckley?) switching between flutes and strings throughout the track (you can actually hear the heads shifting between sounds in places), but there may also be some on Everybody Here Wants You, with cellos and strings in the mix, though it's difficult to say if they're 'Tron or generic samples. Either way, one in-your-face 'Tron track, and one possibility. Difficult to recommend on the Mellotron front, but difficult not to for everything else. Buy.
By the way, watch for disc two's demo version of Genesis' Back In NYC from The Lamb...
Budgie (1971, 40.40) ****½/½Guts
Everything in My Heart
Nude Disintegrating Parachutist Woman
Rape of the Locks
All Night Petrol
You and I
Squawk (1972, 38.58) ***½/TTTWhisky River
Rolling Home Again
Make Me Happy
Hot as a Docker's Armpit
Young is a World
Budgie were, and for that matter are again, a hard rock trio from south Wales, a heavily industrial area conducive to such goings-on (see: Birmingham). Unlike most of their brethren, however, they had a sense of humour and many of their song titles have become legendary, not to mention their bizarre lyrics. Sadly, their chief claim to fame these days is being multiply covered by Metallica on various b-sides and EPs; believe me, they're worth more.
Although vocalist/bassist Burke Shelley is also credited with 'Melotron' (anyone would think the instrument's name wasn't prominently displayed on its casing...), there is very little to be heard on their debut effort. In fact, the only discernable 'Tron is a couple of sustained string chords, well down in the mix, on the superbly-titled Nude Disintegrating Parachutist Woman. The album as a whole is seriously riff-based hard rock, something slightly like a bluesier Black Sabbath, but without the cod-Satanism. The production is awful; it actually varies from track to track, with an appallingly sludgy guitar sound that does the band no favours whatsoever. For all that, it's a great album (!); if early-'70s UK hard rock's your bag, get it.
By Squawk, Budgie really went to town with the 'Tron. Oddly enough, there's absolutely no credit for it on the sleeve, but it's probably safe to assume that Burke Shelley did the honours again. Some 'clicky' flutes on Rolling Home Again and brass and strings on Hot As A Docker's Armpit are all well and good, but on Young Is A World they go completely over the top. This is a full-blown Mellotron epic, no less, strings everywhere you look and well worth the ear of any 'Tron fan. Overall, the album's similar to their first, although I personally feel that the songs aren't up to scratch in comparison. So, buy? First: only if you like the style anyway; Second: for the 'Tron.
Boat With No Oars (2007, 60.02) **½/T
No Turning Back
Salt and Pepper
West is the West
My Sweet Warrior
The City Trees
Baby I Love You
|Chocolate and Hawaii
Suitcase Full of Feathers
Minneapolis' Mary Bue is a singer-songwriter of the piano (as against guitar) variety, whose fourth album, 2007's Boat With No Oars, sails too close to the indie mainstream for this listener's liking, less tiresome tracks including West Is The West and Big Mistake.
Bue plays Chamberlin (recorded at Minneapolis' Third Ear Studio. Their machine?), with big, chordal strings on Gorgeous, although, sadly, that's our lot. Not only is this boring, but it's boring and overlong, although its lone Chamby track is worth hearing, if only for that reason.
Long Play 33⅓ [a.k.a. The Albatross, by Gary Stier] (2000/2002, 58.02) ***/T½
|This Ain't Nowhere
Miss America and I
Coming Up Roses
Ragged Out Heart
|What You Don't Need
Tied to the Tracks
One Man's Ceiling
Let it All Come Down
[Stier version adds:
All My Fault]
Here's a slightly confusing one: Buffalo Nickel (named for an iconic version of the 5¢ piece)'s debut album, Long Play 33⅓, was subsequently reissued two years later as The Albatross, by by-then ex-vocalist Gary Stier, (almost) same tracklisting and all. It's got a very Tom Petty/John Mellencamp sound about it, so it's no surprise at all to find out that Heartbreakers Mike Campbell and Benmont Tench play on the record, along with Kenny Aronoff from Mellencamp's band and workaholic Jayhawk Gary Louris. It's not a bad record, but given that better practitioners of the style are still working, it seems a slightly pointless one, which I'm sure is missing the point quite badly. C'est la vie. Heartfelt plea: a few tracks of this stuff is fine, but a whole (long) album really starts to drag after a while. Best track? Probably closer Let It All Come Down, largely because it's a bit rockier.
Joey Huffman plays Mellotron, while Benmont Tench does his usual Chamberlin thing, although there's not a great deal of either to be heard here, I'm afraid. Faint string parts (presumably Mellotron) on Miss America And I and Ragged Out Heart, while the (presumably) Chamby strings on What You Don't Need are far more full-on, although that would appear to be it.
Given that this is a) on a major label and b) still available, howcum Stier's managed to re-release it under his own name? It's got one extra track (All My Fault), although the original's got a vastly better sleeve. I'd be interested to know the full story behind this. Buffalo Nickel seem to have carried on, presumably without him, releasing at least two later albums. All most intriguing. Anyway, you've really got to be into that American 'road trip' stuff to find this particularly interesting; it barely scrapes three stars, to be honest. Not much tape-replay, either, so I wouldn't go too far out of your way for this one.
Adventures in Modern Recording (1981, 33.43) ***½/TAdventures in Modern Recording
I am a Camera
After their huge hit with Video Killed The Radio Star and its associated LP, The Age of Plastic, not to mention their ill-advised teaming-up with Yes for their Drama opus, Trevor Horn and Geoff Downes retreated into the safety of their original outfit, producing a rather less pop-friendly album in Adventures in Modern Recording. It's a clever, assured album, though without an obvious hit, ultimately doomed. After its failure, Horn went into production, of course (Yes, Frankie Goes to Hollywood), while Downes co-formed the appalling Asia with Yes' Steve Howe.
Musically, there are some definite points of interest: Horn does a pretty good Jon Anderson on Lenny, proving he'd learnt something from his Yes experience, while I Am A Camera is a re-write of Into The Lens from Drama, though I'd say they were probably better when doing their own thing. The only obvious Mellotron parts on the album are the choirs on Vermilion Sands and the title track, but even then, they're pretty low-key. So; not bad, not great, little Mellotron. Of its time.
See: Asia | Yes | Bruce Woolley
Perfect From Now on (1997, 54.16) ****/TTRandy Described Eternity
I Would Hurt a Fly
Stop the Show
Out of Site
Kicked it in the Sun
Untrustable Part 2 (About Someone Else)
Ancient Melodies of the Future (2001, 39.16) ****/TTT
In Your Mind
Trimmed and Burning
|Fly Around My Pretty Little Miss
There is No Enemy (2009, 55.33) ***½/T
Good Ol' Boredom
Life's a Dream
Things Fall Apart
Built to Spill are difficult to describe, not least due to having changed their style from one album to the next. 1997's Perfect From Now on sounds to my ears like a cross between Neil Young and the more interesting end of '90s US indie stuff, with a sometimes unpredictable and (dare I say it?) almost progressive approach to their song structures; there are certainly a couple of lengthy tracks on the album, although, of course, that's not necessarily any indicator of a 'progressive' outlook (see: The Allman Brothers). Most of the songs are also suffused with the same kind of melancholy as, say, Low, although BtS are a far 'rockier' proposition all round. Highlights? Stop The Show shoots off at a tangent a couple of times, just to keep things interesting and Velvet Waltz is a classic 'slowburner', but there isn't actually a bad track to be heard here. Robert Roth's Mellotron (and yes, it's real) appears on three tracks, with considerable string use on Made-Up Dreams and Velvet Waltz, although there's less on lengthy closer Untrustable Part 2. BtS have even been known to use Mellotron live, but I'm not even sure if the band are still together at this point.
The band released an excellent live album, er, Live (****), in 2000, finally following Perfect From Now on with Ancient Melodies of the Future in 2001. There seems to've been another minor stylistic shift, with even fewer upbeat tracks, and the album isn't as 'immediate' as its predecessor, although it's quite clearly a good record. There's no Mellotron actually credited, and with two different keyboard players involved, it's hard to tell who's doing what. Sam Coomes guests on three tracks, so it's possible he plays the Mellotron parts on Alarmed and The Weather, while band mainman Doug Martsch plays the rest. Although it's not credited as such, there's plenty of Mellotron onboard here, with strings/cellos on The Host, pitchbent strings on In Your Mind and Alarmed and flute parts on Fly Around My Pretty Little Miss and The Weather. I'm not 100% convinced that all the string parts are actually Mellotron and what sounds like E-bowed guitar on Trimmed And Burning I initially took to be Mellotron strings, but it seems that most of the album has at least a little Mellotronic input.
BtS didn't use a Mellotron for another eight years, until 2009's There is No Enemy. It's a perfectly respectable album, but also a rather unexciting one, most of its tracks dragging on longer than necessary. Look, guys, Neil Young can get away with it and you can onstage, but this is an album, OK? The record certainly has its moments (Nowhere Lullaby, closer Tomorrow), but could have done with being fifteen minutes shorter. Coomes alone plays Mellotron this time round, but not a lot... He's credited on one track, with under a minute of strings on Done, although Tomorrow also features a string part that's quite clearly Mellotron-generated. Not a bad album, then, but nowhere near a great one, either.
Anyway, Perfect From Now on is excellent, with Ancient Melodies... being nearly as good (though There is No Enemy is rather lesser, sadly), with a cautious recommendation on the Mellotron front for the former, and a more positive one for the latter. n.b. Brian tells me that they used a real M400 live as recently as 2009, making it highly likely that the Mellotron on that year's album is real.
See: Samples etc. | Robert Roth
Smasher (1974, 33.07) **/T
Are You Really Happy Together
Bad Bad Girl
Brown Eyed Handsome Man
We All Had a Real Good Time
Ooh When You Smile
Rock'n'Roll Hootchie Coo
|I Tip My Hat
I Tried to Sleep
Bulldog formed in 1971 from the ashes of The Rascals, apparently surprising people by not sounding like that band; odd, given that they didn't even share a vocalist. Why would they? Anyway, their debut, 1972's Bulldog, is the kind of album that can only be described as 'rock'; not especially heavy, certainly not at all progressive, not really... anything. This sounds like a jumped-up bar band with a couple of 'names' who got lucky, then couldn't quite decide what musical path to follow.
Their second (and last) effort from two years later, Smasher, is even less 'rock' than its predecessor, opening with several quiet numbers, while the rockier tracks are pretty half-hearted, as you'd expect. John Turi plays Mellotron, with flutes on opener Flamingo and closer I Tried To Sleep, bookending the album, although the strings on a handful of tracks appear to be real; the chord at the end of Honeymoon Couple definitely holds too long to be Mellotronic. All in all, a pretty disappointing effort, to be honest, with so little definite Mellotron that purchase on those grounds, especially of an out-of-print item, would be futile.
Lookaftering (2005, 35.37) ****½/T
Against the Sky
If I Were
Same But Different
Feet of Clay
Until 2002, Vashti Bunyan (descendant of John) resided, seemingly permanently, in the 'Where are they now?' file, having left behind one perfect album in 1970's gorgeous Just Another Diamond Day (*****), subsequently disappearing into obscurity. The much-fêted Devendra Banhart helped her reappear in the whatever-we're-calling-this-decade, with her second album, Lookaftering, appearing in 2005, 35 years after her debut. Was it worth the wait? Oh yes... It's hard to say at this stage whether it's quite as good as ...Diamond Day, but Vashti's gentle, intimate voice remains almost unchanged, along with her beautiful songs; a female Nick Drake, anyone? I think it'll take more listens than I have time to give this now for its charms to become fully apparent, so I'm not even going to try to pinpoint highlights, only to say that this is one of the most stunning singer-songwriter albums you'll hear all year, or probably decade.
Producer Max Richter plays keyboard, wind and percussion instruments on the album, including Mellotron on three tracks. Against The Sky and Turning Backs have sublime flute parts that could almost have been played by a real one, with the latter juxtaposing it against a cor anglais, plus what I take to be a very background flute part on Feet Of Clay, as there's nothing else obvious on the track. Real? It's hard to tell, but I'm inclined to leave this here, at least for now. Anyway, you shouldn't be buying this for its fairly low Mellotronic content, but for its pastoral beauty and because Vashti Bunyan needs to be welcomed back. Quite beautiful.
Burek V (2003, 45.09) **/½
Fa Fa Fa
Too Happy Now
Carry No Evil
Cover Your Tracks
Singled Out Blues
I know so little about Burek V that I can't even tell you whether it's 'V' as in the twenty-second letter of the alphabet, or as in the Roman 'five', although, for what it's worth (often, not that much), Discogs list their eponymous 2003 effort as their first of two albums, their last release being in 2005. Burek V is, I'm sad to report, an utterly dreary indie album, at its least tedious on Cover Your Tracks, although the bluesy acoustic slide work on closer Singled Out Blues almost makes for a decent song.
Tom Hakava (Ben's Diapers, Witchcraft) plays (presumably) his own Mellotron on Two Strings, with a brief, upfront, wobbly chordal flute part, although the strings on Heliocentricity sound like an old string synth.
Lost Photograph (2002, 45.27) ***½/T
The Couch Episode
Linguist From Latvia
Dem Monatstrishter Rebin's Chosid'l
Arturo, the Aqua Boy
The Cantor and His Grandson
Long Islander Rob Burger's Lost Photograph has been described as 'very Jewish', and that's by a website called Klezmershack, so I think they know what they're talking about... It's actually a ripe mixture of klezmer and other East European Jewish styles, allied to anything and everything that Burger could lay his hands on, musically speaking. The album's cohesiveness in the face of considerable diversity is aided and abetted by Burger's accordion, present on most tracks, giving the whole an almost pre-war air in places.
Burger plays Chamberlin, with, er, something on Storyteller, along with strings. Woodwind? Very hard to tell, but it's clearly coming from a tape-replay instrument. So; something a little different for this site... Lost Photograph is clearly very good at what it does, which is pretty unique, something that almost invariably gets brownie points 'round these parts. One decent Chamby track, but I doubt whether that'll tempt any but those of you who like the sound of Burger's thang anyway.
See: Faun Fables | Oranj Symphonette | Great Jewish Music
Faith to Fall (2010, 41.57) **½/T
|The High Road
Cross the Street
Shades of Gray
State of Grace
|Far Away Here
Faith to Fall
Kate Burkart's Faith to Fall doesn't appear to be a Christian album, which is a bonus, although its gentle-end-of-Americana thing loses its appeal after a few tracks. Any highlights? Opener The High Road, the drone-friendly Cross The Street and Destined, perhaps.
Matt Henry Cunitz plays his M400 on Parallel Universe, with a clearly genuine string part, as upfront as you like. Sadly, I really can't think of anything much else to say about this, although I have to note that Burkart's lyrics are largely above-average, which makes a nice change.
Darling, Maybe Someday (2008, 38.20) **½/T
|Blue as the Sky
Gales of November
I Need Your Love
Carry You With Me
|Everything You Said
Too Far Gone
You're on My Mind
End of the Road
Tyler Burkum sounds like he should be a full-blown country dude, but is actually a rather drippy singer-songwriter with an occasional country edge. 2008's Darling, Maybe Someday isn't all bad, just mostly, better efforts including the Neil Young-ish I Need Your Love and forlorn closer End Of The Road, although they do little to make up for the rest of the album.
Paul Moak plays Mellotron, with a short strings solo on opener Blue As The Sky and a full-on polyphonic flute part on End Of The Road, which improve their parent songs without making much impact on the album overall. Weak singer-songwriter fare, not much Mellotron. Business as usual, then.